Two days before Christmas in 1823, a small newspaper in Troy, New York — the Sentinel — printed an anonymous poem submitted by a reader. It began: “‘Twas the night before Christmas, when all through the house…”
Fifty-six lines later, the modern Santa Claus existed.
What Santa looked like before the poem
It’s easy to assume Santa was always Santa. He wasn’t. Before 1823, St. Nicholas appeared in stories and engravings mostly as what he had actually been: a lean, solemn bishop in robes, arriving on his feast day of December 6th to reward the good and warn the wayward. Dutch tradition gave him a horse and a book of names. Nobody gave him a belly laugh.
A Visit from St. Nicholas changed nearly everything in a single sitting. The poem invented or cemented:
- The night before Christmas as the visit’s date — moving the magic from December 6th to Christmas Eve
- The flying sleigh and eight reindeer — named for the first time: Dasher, Dancer, Prancer, Vixen, Comet, Cupid, Donder, and Blitzen
- The chimney entrance, described with cheerful matter-of-factness
- The look: a “right jolly old elf” with a round belly, twinkling eyes, a pipe, and a sack of toys — not a bishop but something warmer, stranger, and friendlier
- The silence: he speaks not a word, does his work, and vanishes — mystery intact
Later artists — most famously Thomas Nast in his Harper’s Weekly illustrations, and eventually twentieth-century advertising — added the red suit, the North Pole workshop, and the scale. But the character was born in those fifty-six lines.
The mystery of who wrote it
Here’s where the story turns literary detective. For years the poem stayed anonymous. In 1837 it was attributed to Clement Clarke Moore, a wealthy New York professor of biblical languages, who later included it in an 1844 collection of his poetry. The traditional account says Moore wrote it for his children and never intended it to be published — a friend supposedly sent it to the newspaper without his knowledge.
But descendants of another New Yorker, Henry Livingston Jr., have long claimed their ancestor wrote it — pointing out that the poem’s bouncing anapestic rhythm and playful Dutch flavor match Livingston’s known verse far better than Moore’s stern, scholarly poems. Literary scholars have argued both sides, some quite forcefully, and the authorship question remains one of American literature’s most charming unsolved cases.
Whoever wrote it gave us something rare: a poem so absorbed into culture that most people can recite lines they never consciously learned.
Why fifty-six lines conquered the world
The poem succeeded because it did something no sermon about St. Nicholas ever had: it made the sacred visitor domestic. The saint enters an ordinary family home, in an ordinary night’s silence, and the father who witnesses it isn’t terrified — he’s delighted. Wonder, the poem suggests, might land on your own roof.
That’s the deeper gift. Every child who has ever strained to hear hooves on the shingles is living inside a piece of literature — proof that a few well-made lines can build a tradition sturdy enough to hold two centuries of Christmas Eves.
Follow the story further
The poem also fixed another custom in place — the stockings “hung by the chimney with care.” The strange, tender history behind that one is here: Why Do We Hang Stockings?
Sources & Further Reading
- A Visit from St. Nicholas (1823), first printed in the Troy Sentinel — read the poem free at Project Gutenberg
- Poetry Foundation — A Visit from St. Nicholas (full text and notes)
- On the authorship question: Clement Clarke Moore, Poems (1844); the Livingston family claim is surveyed in Don Foster, Author Unknown (2000)
Every tradition has a story. Browse the library or subscribe below for one story behind the season each week.